Beckwith has nothing to say, merely a shameful ad hominem attack. Crothers has clearly hit a nerve. No legitimate scientist would respond to Crother's analysis the way Beckwith has responded. Does he really have a Ph.D.? I don't think so. I have a Ph.D. and I've never met a Ph.D. scientist who would behave in such an unprofessional manner. He seems to be a fraud.
Andrew Beckwith writes like an illiterate thug, not a PhD holder, one can tell from his replies that Mr Crothers has hit a nerve. Gee, they have become so desperate to defend their belief system they resort to name calling, if not ignorance.